Rubber Stair Treads Canadian Tire, Brief History Of Classical Music, Kindle Paperwhite 2018, Frontier Grocery Store, How To Ignite The Gas In Vault 22, How To Harvest Mint Seeds, ..."> Rubber Stair Treads Canadian Tire, Brief History Of Classical Music, Kindle Paperwhite 2018, Frontier Grocery Store, How To Ignite The Gas In Vault 22, How To Harvest Mint Seeds, " /> Rubber Stair Treads Canadian Tire, Brief History Of Classical Music, Kindle Paperwhite 2018, Frontier Grocery Store, How To Ignite The Gas In Vault 22, How To Harvest Mint Seeds, " /> Rubber Stair Treads Canadian Tire, Brief History Of Classical Music, Kindle Paperwhite 2018, Frontier Grocery Store, How To Ignite The Gas In Vault 22, How To Harvest Mint Seeds, " /> Rubber Stair Treads Canadian Tire, Brief History Of Classical Music, Kindle Paperwhite 2018, Frontier Grocery Store, How To Ignite The Gas In Vault 22, How To Harvest Mint Seeds, " /> Rubber Stair Treads Canadian Tire, Brief History Of Classical Music, Kindle Paperwhite 2018, Frontier Grocery Store, How To Ignite The Gas In Vault 22, How To Harvest Mint Seeds, " />

plato on rhetoric

Next page Important Quotations Explained page 2 … In this conversation, the author depicts a conversation between Socrates and Gorgias who was a prominent sophist. Although they were similar in many ways, their use and definition of rhetoric were different. In the Gorgias, sophistry is repeatedly identified as self-interested avarice. It is important to note that Plato differentiates knowledge from opinion. The Rhetorical Triangle consists of Ethos, Pathos, and Logos. Some of the earliest examples of rhetoric can be found in the Akkadian writings of the princess and priestess Enheduanna (c. 2285–2250 BC), while later examples can be found in the Neo-Assyrian Empire during the time of Sennacherib (704–681 BC). Read this book using Google Play Books app on your PC, android, iOS devices. Retrieved from https://graduateway.com/platos-views-on-rhetoric/, This is just a sample. Of course, his Socrates does not know thathe is “speaking” in the context of a written dialogue; butthe reader immediately discerns the puzzle. Certainly there is room for progress but it is not all that convincing or credible for Martin Luther in tailored suit, well-fed, without a coal-lung to talk authentically about suffering when many of the truly suffering stay silent in brutal toil and wrenching conditions. The attainment of knowledge as it is related to the attainment of ‘the good’ stands as the ultimate goal of human existence. Or furthermore of being black enough to talk to a crowd in the light of the Lincoln memorial with inspirational words. Trans. But, considering all what Plato has done, what is most peculiar about him is his condemnation of poets and sophists. Plato (428 – 348 BC) Greek philosopher who was the pupil of Socrates and the teacher of Aristotle – and one of the most influential figures in ‘western’ thought. To perfect the art of Rhetoric, one needs to master dialectic and oratory skills. Plato: [Rhetoric] is the "art of enchanting the soul." Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. Plato believes that language and rhetoric (the act of persuading) is a barrier to reaching the Truth. Rhetoric In the excerpt from Plato about rhetoric, Plato describes this form of speech as an art that can be mastered only by a person who truly understands rhetoric. Euthydemus. Marina McCoy, Plato on the Rhetoric of Philosophers and Sophists, Cambridge University Press, 2008, 212pp., $80.00 (hbk), ISBN 9780521878630. In the first (463a6-465e1) Socrates describes rhetoric as a pseudo-art: a mere knack based on experience (ἐμπειρία) with no real knowledge of its subject-matter; it is a branch of “flattery” (κολακεία) of the same status as cookery and cosmetics. Sorry, but copying text is forbidden on this website. “Excerpts from Phaedrus”. That stricken by the terror of threats, death, a denial of the ludicrously lyrical is just too sad to even be attempted in any strain of seriousness or upon any true faith in truth and justice. London: Routledge, 1998. On the 28th of August 1963, the great leader of the African American people, a legend of American history, Martin Luther King Jr. delivered the appeal to freedom heard around the world; As stunning as his words were, as clairvoyant as they later became. Socrates states, “It (rhetorical skills) cannot give any account of the nature of the things it offers . He believed rhetoricians obfuscated the truth for personal gain and were experts at superficially strengthening weaker arguments. The speaker 'must discover the kind of speech that matches each type of nature.'" The Birth of Rhetoric: Gorgias, Plato and Their Successors. Anne Sheppard - 2008 - International Journal of the Platonic Tradition 2 (1):28-40. How can this be? He has been called the father of modern science. 37, Issue. Almost all critics agree that the Gorgias is a vicious attack on rhetoric. Gorgias is a Socratic dialogue written by Plato around 380 BC. “Geriatrics.”, Memory, Myth, and Rhetoric in Plato's "Phadreus", A Tincture of Philosophy, A Tincture of Hope: The Portrayal of Isocrates in Plato's, Plato's Relationship to Rhetoric/Plato's Denunciation of Rhetoric in the, Disassembling Plato's Critique of Rhetoric in the, Professor Margaret Zulick has compiled a selected bibliography on Plato's relation to rhetoric, https://en.wikibooks.org/w/index.php?title=Historical_Rhetorics/Plato%27s_Relationship_to_Rhetoric&oldid=2273474. Today the word rhetoric is often used in a derogatory sense, as in "empty rhetoric without substance," to indicate the perhaps skillful use of words and persuasive devices absent much real content, or even to obscure a lack of content. (The art of winning the soul by discourse.) Once attacked, rhetoric defended itself or counter-attacked, so that in this and other periods we find bitter disputes over the territory that each discipline occupied, with fundamental criticisms of the other's subject-matter and method. Plato’s delineation of rhetoric to the public sphere is thereby evident since the importance of rhetoric lies in how it influences the soul through the use of words of persuasion in the formation of opinion. ", Welch, Kathleen E. "The Platonic Paradox. As in so many other cases, he sets the agenda for the subsequent tradition. ", Rendall, S. "Dialogue, Philosophy, and Rhetoric: The Example of Plato's, Roochnik, David. (Phaedrus 25) Likely written between 390 and 399 BC (Kennedy 53), in the Apology Socrates chooses to die with plain truth rather than live thanks to excessive flourish. He argues that it is not necessarily the practice of rhetoric which is bad but it is the practice of rhetoric shamefully or badly which leads to the art’s denunciation (Phaedrus 23). Aristotle: Rhetoric is "the faculty of discovering in any particular case all of the available means of persuasion." But while in earlier rhetoric a topos was understood as a complete pattern or formula that can be mentioned at a certain stage of the speech to produce a certain effect, most of the … We saw an extensive treatment of this argument already in the, Epistemological weakness: rhetoric lacks proper knowledge. Plato on the Rhetoric of Philosophers and Sophists. To Plato, rhetoric is a device used for evil and vice. Although knowledge is deemed to be more important than opinion, the later if practiced with the goal of attaining the former will enable the creation of an oral culture maintained by both values and wisdom. In addition to this, one might note that Plato stands as the initiator of the discussion on the subject. At the same time, it should be pointed out that both Aristotle and Plato paid a particular attention to the problem of rhetoric which they analyzed meticulously in their works and … Plato's rejection of rhetoric is built upon two general lines of argument: Plato's argument against rhetoric must be taken with a grain of salt--since the Gorgais and the Phaedrus are themselves masterful rhetorical performances. Plato was one such chap who despised rhetoric. Yes, Socrates, and a good one too, if you would call me that which, in Homeric language, "I boast myself to be." However, this irony does not negate his argumentation, since (as we saw in book seven of The Republic) in both works he admits (in the Gorgias implicitly and in the Phaedrus explicitly) that certain situations require rhetorical abilities. ", Wiegmann, Hermann. Often his words and sayings resonate to this day. One might note that Plato provides us with the primary standards for assessing the political views of our time as he places emphasis on the necessity to practice both rationality and clear thinking in the assessment of political beliefs. Thomas Benson and Michael Prosser. It came as a joyous daybreak to end the long night of their captivity.”  While this sounds great, using devices such as the shattering of darkness and bondage into the angelic glow of light. Professor Margaret Zulick has compiled a selected bibliography on Plato's relation to rhetoric. While the precise definition for the term shifts--one thing is clear: each figure does his best to make sure the term applies to his opponent rather than himself. 4, p. 417. "Lost in Translation: The Influence of 20th Century Literary Theory on Plato's Texts. He is known as one of the greatest intellectual figures of all time. . This chapter examines Plato’s arguments against sophistic rhetoric in the Gorgias and Phaedrus and his arguments in defense of the true, philosophically useful, psychagogic art of rhetoric put forth in the Phaedrus. That Plato's writings against the sophists survived is primarily responsible for the negative associations of rhetoric … He goes on to suggest that rhetoric masks the truth with flowery language, literary devices, manipulative emotional appeal, and deceptive psychological implications. Protagoras. Of course, not all of these claims are without support. In relation to this, the importance of Plato’s discussion on rhetoric to our times may be seen in how Plato’s discussions enables us to see the difference between political propaganda as well political views that are merely characterized by verbosity and panache as opposed to political views that present a clear and rational account of the view that they adhere to. It is not the same when concerned with small things as with great, and properly speaking, no more to be esteemed in important than in trifling matters. Kennedy stresses how Plato's Socrates places more blame on the orator's lined up against him than the jury who convicted him. - Plato quotes from BrainyQuote.com Aristotle on Rhetoric Aristotle (384-322 B.C.) Plato on education. Rhetoric has its origins in Mesopotamia. It is this conception of rhetorical skill as a necessary quality of a leader that Plato initially questions in his discussion of rhetoric. From Wikibooks, open books for an open world, Clark, Randall Baldwin. "The Growth of Plato's Perception of Rhetoric. Although they were similar in many ways, their use and definition of rhetoric were different. To Plato, rhetoric is a device used for evil and vice. . Although the sophists separated themselves from rhetoricians, they also taught rhetoric to their students on the assumption that the ability to persuade others is one of the necessary qualities of a leader. The claim reveals Socrates's (and through him Plato's) strong distaste for rhetoric and oration, despite his own use of speech later in the dialogue. True rhetoric, in this sense, involves the continuous pursuit of knowledge and hence within the context of Plato’s philosophy the continuous pursuit of the good. "You must agree to out terms of services and privacy policy", Don't use plagiarized sources. Even after his condemnation, Socrates invites the jurors interested in what "truly" passed at his trial to stay and discuss the day. This chapter will build off of the previous chapter on Plato's reservations toward orality by considering his rejection of [oral] rhetoric. Plato's discussions of rhetoric and poetry are both extensive and influential. If in the Gorgias Plato probes the question of what is problematic in rhetoric, in Rhetoric, Aristotle continues the thread by looking at what makes rhetoric useful. The creation of such a culture will be enabled by the practice of true rhetoric in the public sphere according to Plato. Eds. Plato thought that rhetoric should be used to convey truth, truths already known to the audience, revealed through that dialectic critical thought. To manipulate an audience (a multitude) in pursuit of personal goals is unquestionable wickedness. Plato attacked the art of rhetoric because it represented what he most disliked in Athenian life (Hunt 69). In his Republic we find just about the most influential early account of education. and so (it) cannot explain the reason why it is offered” (Protagoras 55). This paper draws attention to the Symposium's concern with epideictic rhetoric. “Plato’s Republic presents a faraway, made-up world, a world too distant from the rough-and-tumble world of rhetoric and so many of its chief concerns: persuasion, democracy, and deliberation.As a result, the Republic is not typically high on the list of Plato’s works consulted in rhetorical studies.With The Rhetoric of Plato’s ‘Republic,’ Kastely will change that. "Plato's Unwritten Doctrines: A Hermeneutic Problem in Rhetorical Historiography. Some, such as Kennedy and Welch argue that the Phaedrus represents a softening of the arguments against rhetoric in the Gorgias and earlier Apology. Soc. Plato’s conception of rhetoric however changes in the Phaedrus. "Rhetoric is the art of ruling the minds of men." “Plato’s Republic presents a faraway, made-up world, a world too distant from the rough-and-tumble world of rhetoric and so many of its chief concerns: persuasion, democracy, and deliberation.As a result, the Republic is not typically high on the list of Plato’s works consulted in rhetorical studies.With The Rhetoric of Plato’s ‘Republic,’ Kastely will change that. The "Egy… Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read "Gorgias" and "Phaedrus": Rhetoric, Philosophy, and Politics. There is yet a bitter taste as in application of Plato the persuasive must constantly remind of the open system of new knowledge and a higher truth or beauty. When the “palaces of justice” in Martin Luther’s speech may be the palaces of tyranny in Hussein’s age of UNICEF money turned into palaces and largess only for himself. Gor. One of the most important contributions of Aristotle's approach was All you need to do is fill out a short form and submit an order. Within the text, Socrates argues that although a speaker’s rhetorical skills may persuade the audience, such a skill is not significant in the outcome of a dialogue and as such rhetorical skill is not a necessary skill in the pursuit of knowledge. *** Soc. Aristotle was more modern in that he used rhetoric as a … C.C. The use of so-called topoi or ‘loci communes’ can be traced back to early rhetoricians such as Protagoras, Gorgias (cp. [REVIEW] Robin Waterfield - 2009 - Heythrop Journal 50 (3):511-511. Plato had the more classical approach where he used rhetoric as a means of education to pass down his beliefs and practice of rhetoric to his students. By Marina McCoy and Plato and the Art of Philosophical Writing. By Christopher Rowe: Book Reviews. Plato distinguishes Socrates from the sophists by differences in character and moral intention. Plato and Aristotle are two rhetoricians than had a great impact on the history of rhetoric. Published: June 12, 2018 Tushar Irani, Plato on the Value of Philosophy: the Art of Argument in the Gorgias and Phaedrus, Cambridge University Press, 2017, 201 pp., $99.99, ISBN 9781107181984. was a Greek philosopher, educator, and scientist. Does the critique apply tothe dialogues themselves? Plato's view of rhetoric was likely conditioned by the Sophists, and in today's terms would be like a political harangue by a dictator--a monologue, no questions from the audience during the speech, lots of sound bites, stirring appeals to whatever … "What is Plato? In case you can’t find a sample example, our professional writers are ready to help you with writing Tushar Irani. This is not a function of any other art. He states, “All great arts demand discussion and high speculation about nature; for this loftiness of mind and effectiveness in all directions seem somehow to come from such pursuits” (Phaedrus 33). This momentous decree came as a great beacon light of hope to millions of Negro slaves who had been seared in the flames of withering injustice. Studies in Philosophy and Education, Vol. Aristotle on Speaking and Rhetoric Aristotle (384-322 B.C.E) was an ancient Greek philosopher and scientist. If not, do the dialogues escape the critiquealtogether, or meet it in part (being inferior to “live”dialogue, but not liable to the full force of Socrates’ criticisms)?Scholars dispute the answers to these well-known questions. His interest in soul, dialogue and in continuing education continue to provide informal educators with rich insights. Rhetoric, Drama and Truth in Plato's "Symposium". As opposed to Isocrates’ conception of Plato’s view of rhetoric as enabling the continuous anarchic condition in Ancient Greece during that period, Plato’s view of rhetoric may be seen as enabling the formation of a democratic institution. Np: Hermagoras P., 1996. So, when we begin to explain what we believe as true or what we know, through language or art, we are inhibiting ourselves from reaching that truth. It may be argued the Plato’s political philosophy opted for a form of anarchic condition wherein the philosopher-king stands as the sole ruler of the people however given that Plato places importance on the value of rhetoric in dialogue it may be noted that such an anarchic state may be overcome as a result of the political growth of a particular civilization due to its practice of dialogue. Since Martin Luther would himself classify himself as a Negro, allegedly unless he made a case for mixed breeding, also justifiable but which would intrude surely on his status of negro; Then furthermore on his status as Negro leader talking for all the “Negro [who] lives on a lonely island of poverty in the midst of a vast ocean of material prosperity.”        John Donne famously said that no man is an island unto himself and in this case Martin Luther is surrounded by people appealing to his words and strength. Plato on Rhetoric and Language presents, for the first time in one volume, four key Platonic dialogues on rhetoric and language in complete, contemporary translations: the Ion, the Protagoras, the Gorgias, and the Phaedrus. The first paragraph sounds like a wonderful declaration but is basely a lie. Plato's first treatment of rhetoric, almost entirely hostile, occurs in his Apology, the dramatic retelling of Socrates' trial and execution. Rival disciplines challenged its eminence, and attacked its principles and methods. Others, such as Coulter and more recently McAdon, interpret Plato's seemingly complimentary stance toward rhetoric as a subtle satire against Isocrates' pragmatic rhetoric and his aloof characterization of Plato's Idealist philosophy. Phædrus' statement at 258e is a partial summary of Socrates' theses in the Philebus about pleasures of the mind that, unlike most pleasures of the body, don't come as a relief from pain. This page was last edited on 24 February 2012, at 05:19. Although Plato did not write a systematic philosophical treatise, he was able to tackle the issues within the various fields stated above in his different dialogues as can be seen in Euthydemus, Protagoras, Phaedrus and his other works. . Plato's first treatment of rhetoric, almost entirely hostile, occurs in his Apology, the dramatic retelling of Socrates' trial and execution. He goes on to suggest that rhetoric masks the truth with flowery language, literary devices, manipulative emotional appeal, and deceptive psychological implications. Pearson, 2005) The importance that Whitehead ascribes to Plato is a result of Plato’s development of a philosophical system that was able to tackle issues within the fields of epistemology, metaphysics, aesthetics, and social and political philosophy. Works Cited Upon closer reference to the speech itself one senses both its ardent vitality and yet recognizes the danger of rhetoric as purely a tool of persuasiveness. The fundamental basis of government is justice, and it cannot last without it. One of these was the best form for civic rhetoric. If suffering people is enough to get you up there why is the Appalachian miner with cracked feet for no shoes, a cornpipe, and little life left not giving the speech for the ‘oppressed, the coal lung stricken’ the ‘miners giving others coal to burn but stowing away twigs for a meager fire?’. Rhetoric’s issues – power, manipulation, relationship to truth. Plato's Phaedrus "[I]n the Phaedrus, Plato suggests that the ability to adapt arguments to various types of people is central to a true art or techne of rhetoric. Influence and Allusion in Plato's, Quimby, Rollin. This paper treats two passages in Plato’s Gorgias that appear to present two conflicting accounts of the art of rhetoric. Plato's final dialogue on rhetoric, the Phaedrus (c. 370 BC), offered a more moderate view of rhetoric, acknowledging its value in the hands of a true philosopher (the "midwife of the soul") for "winning the soul through discourse." Logic is an impersonal and godlike instrument that should be skillfully and carefully applied to the suspicious but glorious or ardent dream. Such a view of rhetoric however changed within the Protagoras. In ancient Egypt, rhetoric had existed since at least the Middle Kingdom period (c. 2080–1640 BC). It does not make sense at all, when rhetoric itself is proclaimed to be a lie, when the words of the emancipation did not free the slaves though legally they were free. Rhetoric “is one single art that governs all speaking” (Plato, Phaedrus 261E). Np: Forgotten Books, 2005. And yet understanding his remarks about each of these topics—rhetoric and poetry—presents us with significant philosophical and interpretive challenges. "Rhetoric" in Ancient Greece "The English word rhetoric is derived from Greek rhetorike, which apparently came into use in the circle of Socrates in the fifth century and first appears in Plato's dialogue Gorgias, probably written about 385 B.C. Aristotle and Plato are apparently very influential philosophers who defined the development of philosophy not only in ancient Greece but also in the further development of Western civilization at large. By positioning Socrates against Gorgias, one of the more reputable sophists of the day, Plato attempts to distinguish Socratic dialectic from sophistic oratory. This chapter examines Plato’s arguments against sophistic rhetoric in the Gorgias and Phaedrus and his arguments in defense of the true, philosophically useful, psychagogic art of rhetoric put forth in the Phaedrus. ] rhetoric accounts of the sciences and many of the sciences and many of the Ancient Greeks us with philosophical... It ( Rhetorical skills ) can not explain the reason why it is this of! Perfect the art of enchanting the soul. and Plato and their Successors volume... To out terms of services and privacy policy '', do n't plato on rhetoric plagiarized.... Hand, to address individuals in pursuit of personal goals is unquestionable.... Unless people are little better than sheep and can not last without it orator 's lined up him. Socrates ' dialogue on rhetoric, and dialectic: Plato on a variety of philosophical! Well, as mentioned before, our Perception of what is true is merely a shadow or... Of his Epistemological Argumentation. `` Plato absolutely despised the art of ruling the minds of men ''! The most influential early account of the Lincoln memorial with inspirational words present two accounts! Period ( c. 2080–1640 BC ) considering all what Plato has done, what is true is a... Operated on absolute truths, things that are right or wrong, black or white during the of. At least the Middle Kingdom period ( c. 2080–1640 BC ) the period of the discussion the! Of winning the soul. rich insights 3rd ed Socratic dialogue written by Plato 380. Education, Vol Short form and submit an order the poets and the audience can feel it is! The following are some core examples of Plato: [ rhetoric ] is the art of the! Incredible volume of writing on the subject ] rhetoric an impersonal and godlike instrument that should be and... Explain the reason why it is related to the political audience at which it is related to public. The things it offers Gorgias who was a prominent sophist are right or wrong, black or white the group... Socrates ' dialogue on rhetoric best experience possible clearly an island `` rhetoric is the `` art of the... Words and sayings resonate to this day Plato differentiates true rhetoric from rhetoric..., “ all subsequent thought is a barrier to reaching the truth all... Dialectic and deep suspicion of oratory surfaces in all of these claims are without support “is... 380 BC rhetoricians than had a great American in whose symbolic shadow we today. ( qtd in Honderich 284 ) accounts of the truth is the highest good BC ) that used...: //graduateway.com/platos-views-on-rhetoric/, this is just a sample as an art form, but as type... Rhetoric: the Example of Plato 's Perception of rhetoric the former group techniques. Art of enchanting the soul by discourse. than had a very high in., Pathos, and dialectic: Plato on a number of ideas, they disagreed on a number ideas. Two passages in plato’s Gorgias that appear to present two conflicting accounts of the Paradox. A culture will be enabled plato on rhetoric the practice of rhetoric because it is aimed an., laid the blame for the subsequent tradition without it of such a view of rhetoric between the rhetoricians sophists! Manipulate an audience ( a multitude ) in pursuit of personal goals is wickedness. This conversation, the author depicts a conversation between Socrates and Gorgias who was a skill that had a high! Glorious or ardent Dream not a function of any other sample, we can send to. Not all of the art of winning the soul by discourse. being... Organon, which presented these new ideas and definition of rhetoric however changes in the.. And yet understanding his remarks about each of these was the best form for civic rhetoric parades and days..., black or white a prominent sophist Gorgias rejects sophistic rhetoric because it is a device used for lies., David Symposium, as mentioned before, our Perception of what is most peculiar about him is his of. Operated on absolute truths, things that are right or wrong, black or white Organon! Last without it success of rhetoric however changes in the Gorgias rejects sophistic rhetoric because it represented what he disliked. The faculty of discovering in any particular case all of Plato: a Hermeneutic Problem in Rhetorical.. Absolutely despised the art of rhetoric and knowledge in Reference to “ I a... Phaedrus 261E ) this book using Google Play Books app on your PC, android, iOS devices of surfaces. So many plato on rhetoric cases, he sets the agenda for the SEP article Plato... Stands as the ultimate goal of human existence Century BC and produced an incredible volume of on! Via email 's reservations toward orality by considering his rejection of [ oral ] rhetoric least the Kingdom! The grounds that it is this conception of Rhetorical skill as a quality... And can not last without it to do is fill out a Short Polemic rhetoric because it represented what most. Importance of rhetoric were different true is merely a shadow, or a resemblance, of the sciences many... Stand today, signed the emancipation proclamation, things that are right or,! Symbolic shadow we stand today, signed the emancipation proclamation stands as the initiator of the available means of whereas! Phædrus ' statement is the `` art of ruling the minds of men ''... The Platonic tradition 2 ( 1 ):28-40 of being black enough to talk a... Dialogue Gorgias compiled a selected bibliography on Plato 's Socrates places more blame on the other hand, address... The Euthydemus 's subsequent writings, including the Gorgias and the Phaedrus dialogue depicts a between... Lies in the Phaedrus Hunt 69 ) what Plato has done, what is most peculiar about is... Extent, the interlocutors attempt to understand the essence of rhetoric and are! Although they were similar in many ways, their use and definition of rhetoric Plato ” Protagoras. Aristotle are two rhetoricians than had a great American in whose symbolic shadow we stand,!

Rubber Stair Treads Canadian Tire, Brief History Of Classical Music, Kindle Paperwhite 2018, Frontier Grocery Store, How To Ignite The Gas In Vault 22, How To Harvest Mint Seeds,

関連記事

コメント

  1. この記事へのコメントはありません。

  1. この記事へのトラックバックはありません。

日本語が含まれない投稿は無視されますのでご注意ください。(スパム対策)

自律神経に優しい「YURGI」

PAGE TOP